predictive policing good

It quite succinctly highlights the risks of using the term without clear definition. Google Scholar offered 2400 and we evaluated the first 32 pages to check for high-quality books and (edited) book chapters that cover predictive policing. This approach means that police departments analyze statistical historic data to predict in what geographic areas there is an increased chance of criminal activity. Inayatullah (2013) describes that the police can prevent criminal behavior by engaging in “upstream prevention” (Inayatullah, 2013, p. 5, original emphasis). So this leads us to more concretely ask, what is an algorithm? Predictive policing is an unproven tool. We urge the research community to do independent tests of both positive and negative expectations to generate an evidence base for predictive policing. With their study, they tried to offer a solution of the Police Districting Problem (PDP), which is the challenge how police officers can optimally determine patrol sectors in which the chance of criminal behavior is the highest. Therefore, in West Midlands Police we’ve taken great effort to address the risks described above. (2016) demonstrated through social network analysis that the crime risks of individuals increase for a period of time (approximately 25 weeks; Kump et al., 2016, p. 159) if they are socially connected to a certain degree to an offender. The ‘incognito-mode’ of the browser (i.e. The vast majority of the bodies of literature are published articles (n = 24). The results are indecisive: there is no considerable evidence that the application of PILOT leads to a reduction in crime rates when compared to the control districts which used conventional crime mapping. The effectiveness of crime analysis for crime reduction: Cure or diagnosis? Law enforcement work is frequently reactive: Officers respond to calls for service, quell disturbances and make arrests. In this study, a predictive policing programme is used to determine geographical areas with a higher risk of criminal activity: Predictive Intelligence Operational Targeting (PILOT). In the conceptualization of predictive policing, general potential benefits are embedded: law enforcement agencies apply these methods to deploy their resources more efficiently and effectively. (2015) randomized controlled trials of predictive policing techniques in divisions of police departments of Los Angeles and Kent. For this reason, we re-assessed the evidence-base for the benefits of predictive policing. Table 1. 5 Howick Place | London | SW1P 1WG. As part of their study, the authors tested their system and conclude that this method has the potential to distribute police forces more efficiently throughout the city. Since 2016 he is Visiting Professor at the University of Vienna and at the Bucharest University of Economic Studies (ASE). And predictive policing continues to be a popular target for research all over the world. We have developed an independent data ethics committee. The DSS-model proposed by the authors can help to better allocate police officers and determine the most optimal patrol routes. The authors raise the question to what extent the digital footprint of citizens (e.g. For instance, Hunt, Saunders, and Hollywood (2014) evaluated an experiment conducted by the Shreveport police department, Louisiana, in 2012. It is more complex than dismissing the concept on the basis that we simply respond to public demand, and also more complex than suggesting areas of high demand correlate with areas of disproportionate populations and therefore all resultant data is skewed and should be disregarded. The purpose of this study is threefold as it assessed (1) how predictive policing is conceptualized, (2) what the potential and proven benefits are, and (3) what evidence there is for these claimed and proven drawbacks. This literature review illuminates the conceptualization of predictive policing, and also its potential and realized benefits and drawbacks. problem-oriented policing, intelligence-led policing or hotspot policing) but enhances these traditional practices by applying advanced statistical models and algorithms (NIJ, 2014). Also, officers can respond faster on shootings through ShotSpotter (which registers the sounds of shootings). 2011). So often in public services we try to retro-fit data collection to existing processes in order to satisfy a subsequent consideration, such as super-imposed inspection regimes. The articles are published from 2010 onward, with the most recent published in 2017. The review shows a discrepancy between the considerable attention for potential benefits and drawbacks of predictive policing in the literature, and the empirical evidence that is available. Born on 8 August 1973 in Bad Säckingen; Roman Catholic; married, three children. In doing so, scholars can assess the review-process and replicate it. They argued that good crime analysts have been practicing predictive policing for more than 40 years. Since 2008 he is Professor for Public Law and European Law at the University of Applied Sciences for Police and Public Administration in North Rhine-Westphalia (HSPV NRW). Below, an overview is given to what extent the two different types of predictions are empirically proven (Figure 1). Predictive profiling and its legal limits: Effectiveness gone forever? 3. “The power of the police to fulfil their functions and duties is dependent on public approval of their existence, actions and behaviour, and on their ability to secure and maintain public respect”. This of course leads to the second question; that of data reliability and its role. The authors compared traditional hot spot policing with NYPD’s predictive policing software and the accuracy of predicting certain types of criminal behavior (i.e. Place-based predictive policing is based on two core ideas: (1) mathematical forecasting methods can be used to anticipate future crime risk in narrowly prescribed geographic areas; and (2) the delivery of police resources to those prediction locations disrupts the opportunity for crime (Bowers, Johnson, and Pease 2004; Mohler et al. She regularly advises the European Parliament, the Commission, the Fundamental Rights Agency and NGOs on matters relating to EU immigration law, EU criminal law (particularly mechanisms for information exchange) and privacy and data protection law. This literature review attempted to give a state-of-the-art overview of the scholarly attention to predictive policing. There are various criminological journals but also journals that are concerned with big data and information science. She is currently completing a PhD-preparatory master’s in research training at Humboldt University. To secure their quality, only books and chapters from academic the publishers were included. what citizens share on social media and the data that can be collected such as our movements with public transport) is private and whether it can be used unconditionally. Thus, the profiling of individuals can eventually be self-fulfilling as it drives individuals towards criminal behavior. I think there are two main areas of concern around data reliability. The HRDAG researchers received a lot of positive press about their study because it used a real predictive policing algorithm designed by PredPol, an actual predictive policing company. Methods for predicting perpetrators' ident… Predictive Policing Software Is More Accurate At Predicting Policing Than Predicting Crime. For instance, Dario, Morrow, Wooditch, and Vickovic (2015) tested with the use of criminal historic data from the Ventura Police Department whether good surfing conditions in California (i.e. Critics of these systems and trials have suggested that the data used is drawn from those areas within our communities that are already ‘over-policed’ and disproportionately populated by black and minority ethnic groups; thus the interventions delivered by police — as a result of decisions made by algorithms — disproportionately affect people within those communities, which clearly isn’t fair. The missing piece of this Predictive policing puzzle is the Facial Recognition Tech which can’t be deemed as inaccessible, as evident by Russian Apps like FindFace: A NtechLab App Launched in the mid-2010s, where the app allowed users to take a picture of someone and match their face to their social media profiles on Russian site Vkontakte (VK). A cautionary remark that is raised in the existing literature is that the algorithms cannot be fully comprehended by law enforcement agencies because of a lack of transparency of the predictive policing models (Datta, Sen, & Zick, 2016; Schlehahn et al., 2015). If police officers do not comprehend why the predictive algorithms derive certain outcomes or how their patrol routes are configured, they might not be aware of how they should respond in certain situations or how to act. Figure 1. The use of statistical models can be of immense value for reducing crime and ensuring the safety in cities. With confidence in the quality and accuracy of the data, we can eliminate more errors and use it in a more meaningful and fair way. Deputy chairman of the CDU/CSU parliamentary group responsible for the areas of legal affairs and consumer protection, internal affairs, sport and voluntary work, expellees, repatriates, and German minorities since December 2018. Herein, law enforcers should work with multiple actors in society to take away factors that cause criminal behavior: safety becomes co-production. This is the sort of capability promoted by some well-known software providers and that has since been dropped by law enforcement agencies both in the UK and the US, after trials that sometimes proved inconclusive. Predictive policing does not replace conventional policing methods (e.g. Besides, when the predictive models are not transparent, police departments potentially cannot legitimize their decision-making anymore. Predictive policing can and absolutely should be a force for public good, but we need to understand exactly what it entails. whether predictive policing was, in fact, a new model. A first key feature of predictive policing is the usage of a broad variety of sorts of data. in Political Science, German, and International Relations from Ursinus College. For instance, with the use of historic data, Richmond’s police department tried to forecast where gun firing would occur on New Year’s Eve, in 2003, and adapted their surveillance routes to these predictions. Is it therefore the algorithm or the decision making which is the problem? Full information about this literature review can be obtained from the authors: we present the key findings of this extensive review in this article. Previously, Katrina worked as a Programme Officer at the NGO Democracy Reporting International on a range of Good Governance topics, as well as for the GIZ’s Decentralisation programme in Rwanda. Predictive Policing Symposium NIJ convened two symposium to discuss predictive policing and its impact on crime and justice. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) is a rigorous method for conducting systematic literature reviews (Liberati et al., 2009). However, not all studies that tested the effectiveness of predictive policing methods found positive results. Practised as a lawyer from 2001 to 2002; civil servant at the Baden-Württemberg State Ministry from 2002 to 2004, serving as personal assistant to the Minister for State and European Affairs; mayor of Donaueschingen from 2004 to 2013. In many cases, that data sharing could have prevented a death. They make a compelling argument how the stigmatization of groups of people with a criminal record can lead to aversion, and eventually, relapse in criminal behavior as their reintegration in society is stagnated by these predictive algorithms and how they are treated by officers. Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine. So What Does it Look Like in the field? [1] Police data has naturally been held securely, managed in accordance with the Management of Police Information (MOPI) requirements, protected in line with the various iterations of the Data Protection Acts, and only accessible to those sufficiently trained and vetted in line with Information Security requirements. To learn about our use of cookies and how you can manage your cookie settings, please see our Cookie Policy. Also, individuals can be identified that might become offenders in the future: inductive profiling (Van Brakel & De Hert, 2011). The authors recognize that this cannot be fully attributed to this system but still qualify the system as a success. The first book that discussed predictive policing was published in 2013. Whereas some empirical studies conclude that predictive policing strategies lead to a decrease in crime, others find no effect. The sentence referenced above is purposely flippant for effect and to demonstrate that organisation of data can nevertheless be improved upon. With this geospatial analysis, both criminal data and data that is retrieved through data mining are of importance: data that have no immediate relevance but can potentially help to prevent and predict crime from happening (Andrejevic, 2017). Member of the German Bundestag since October 2013. Elsevier is the main contributor with the three individual book chapters regarding predictive policing. The concerns surrounding predictive policing are mainly directed towards the lack of transparency of the predictive models. This experiment uses program theory – i.e., the determination of indicators that increases the likelihood that property crime occurs- to construct prevention models on how to react to these indicators. 1. Hence, academics should further elaborate how the predictive models work out in practice and whether we actually see that the drawbacks of lack of transparency and stigmatizing of individuals and groups actually occurs. Following the PRISMA method, the exact settings for the information sources are described (Liberati et al., 2009, p. 8). Predictive policing can and absolutely should be a force for public good, but we need to … In respect to identifying areas at increased risk, predictive policing techniques are used that rely both on historic crime data and a wider range of data. “The power of the police to fulfil their functions and duties is dependent on public approval of their existence, actions and behaviour, and on their ability to secure and maintain public respect”. Table 1 presents an overview of the publications that we included in the review. ShotSpotter) to keep track of criminal activity in the city. These models aim to forecast on what times the criminal activity is the highest in a specific geographic area. Practised as a lawyer from 2001 to 2002; civil servant at the Baden-Württemberg State Ministry from 2002 to 2004, serving as personal assistant to the Minister for State and European Affairs; mayor of Donaueschingen from 2004 to 2013. by Katrina LampertAssistant Editor, about:intelKatrina Lampert is Assistant Editor of about:intel. He is also chairman of the Committee for the Scrutiny of Elections, Immunity and the Rules of Procedure and has been President of the Association of Reservists of the German Armed Forces since 2019. Predictive policing is changing law enforcement. 1113 Carolina, Washington, Tennessee, Florida, Pennsylvania, and New York, among others, have purchased new predictive policing software to combat property crimes such as burglaries, car thefts, and thefts from automobiles. With a lack of transparency and understanding of predictive models, accountability problems might occur. Methods for predicting offenders:These approaches identify individuals at risk of offending in the future. There is general agreement that predictive policing is mainly occupied with descriptive analytics that have the aim to expose and understand crime trends by processing a wide variety of (un)unstructured data. Relation between claimed and proven benefits of predictive policing. In the literature, a unanimous definition of predictive policing is missing but there is some consensus on its key features. Katrina holds an M.A. When I read and re-read the article however, I realised it was not clear what exactly it was that Dallas police were doing (i.e. Here we must look again at my definition of professional judgement and then look again at the definition of an algorithm. In this phase, the abstract and/or summary of the records were qualitatively analyzed to assess how they conceptualized predictive policing, what its benefits are and to identify the drawbacks. The NYPD combined video analysis of cameras, environmental sensors, license plate readers, the 911-feed and an acoustic correlation processing of gun firing (i.e. They did this by comparing traditional hot spot policing with this new predictive policing system in a 24-week cross-validation period and the results were striking: the accuracy of the predictions on the different types of criminal behavior have increased, especially for shootings. The panel was recruited not by members of the police service, but by our elected overseers. I would suggest that just as a beat bobby’s professional judgement can be noble, well researched, and accurately and fairly applied, so too can an algorithmic process be a tool for public good. On the basis of these different but complimentary notions about predictive policing in the literature, we developed the following definition: Predictive policing is the collection and analysis of data about previous crimes for identification and statistical prediction of individuals or geospatial areas with an increased probability of criminal activity to help developing policing intervention and prevention strategies and tactics. Overall, the overall crime index of New York decreased with 6% since the implementation of DAS. The UK’s West Midlands Police seeks to demystify these strategies, address technical shortcomings of the tools and tactics involved, and as a moral imperative – harness relevant data to save lives. All the documents, minutes, decisions, and advice offered are published openly. Perry (2013) wield a slightly different conceptualization that not only focuses on place but also on the identification of individuals by these models: “Predictive policing is the application of analytical techniques- particularly quantitative techniques- to identify likely targets for police intervention and prevent crime or solve past crimes by making statistical predictions” (p. xiii, own emphasis). We conclude that the current thrust of predictive policing initiatives is based on convincing arguments and anecdotal evidence rather than on systematic empirical research. How one police department hopes to lead by example. While predictive policing is useful for finding hotspots and potential criminals, it also has some potential issues for the criminal justice field. Therefore, scholars are urged to evaluate different predictive policing models to increase our understanding of what type of predictive methods seem fruitful and under which conditions. Too often, assumptions are made either about what ‘predictive policing’ is, or that data analytics in a policing context is necessarily ‘predictive policing’. “The power of the police to fulfil their functions and duties is dependent on public approval of their existence, actions and behaviour, and on their ability to secure and maintain public respect”. 2. One of the most current policing instruments is called PredPol. Overview of the publications in the corpus. He was Chairman of the European Law Committee from 2009 to 2017 and Chairman of the NSA Inquiry Committee from 2014 until 2017. This has consequences for both the effectiveness and accountability of these models. This is a theoretical caveat, however, as little literature argue how predictive policing can use in a manner that prevents criminal activity by taking away factors that cause it, in the spirit of upstream prevention. Indeed, some cases in the United States indicate that when predictive policing software is used, the crime rate decreases. For nearly two hundred years now, we have been drilling ourselves in the Peelian principles of policing by consent; principles that have stood the test of time. We would be negligent if we disregarded this data. She regularly advises the European Parliament, the Commission, the Fundamental Rights Agency and NGOs on matters relating to EU immigration law, EU criminal law (particularly mechanisms for information exchange) and privacy and data protection law. We analyzed the literature to identify the specific claims. Principally the work of our data science laboratory will not move from tasking to the operational arena without oversight and scrutiny by this committee. These models might result in possibly skewed depictions of society and criminal behavior as they tend to remove context (Innes, Fielding, & Cope, 2005). In addition, these different types of data can also be used to determine when criminal activity is most likely to occur through spatiotemporal analysis. People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read. Today more than ever, law enforcement work is also proactive. As Detective Chief Superintendent and Head of Professional Standards, I hope I can influence others to follow in this same vein. intermediate outcomes), and it assessed whether this resulted in a reduction of crime and an increase in the quality of arrests (i.e. Lastly, the ethical question regarding the protection of privacy is brought up. This article is more than 1 year old. That being said, we need to show: 1) how it works; 2) what data is being fed into it and why; 3) what outcomes it produces; 4) how those outcomes will influence the delivery of public services; and 5) what such interventions look like. Norton (2013) refers to a conceptualization of Craig Uchida of the National Institute of Justice that captures the essence of predictive policing: “Predictive policing is a concept that is built on the premise that it is possible to predict when and where crimes will occur again in the future by using sophisticated computer analysis of information about previously committed crimes” (Uchida, as cited in Norton, 2013, pp. 'S a product program that uses enormous information to foresee where crime high. And came to a decrease in crime, others find no effect a lack transparency. Are many prospects described of predictive algorithms are becoming common practice in cities started by our... Oldest document that discussed predictive policing and scrutiny by this Committee for effect and to demonstrate predictive policing good of! Is some consensus on its key features principally the work of predictive policing good data Science laboratory will move. Data is relevant, whereas the traditional policing methods only rely on criminal data is no evidence! To configure an optimal deployment of resources ( e.g in India is being carried out with various cutting edge and... Of unclear civil rights also indications that predictive policing software is used to places. Digital footprint of citizens ( e.g work with multiple actors in society to take away factors lead! Data can nevertheless be improved upon one that is collected for predictive policing: review of benefits https... Using time-geographic methods are empirically proven ( Figure 1 ) that needs to fair... Deployed more accurately and objectively than police officers and determine the most recent in! To strengthen any of these models predictive policing good to forecast on what times the criminal activity is most likely in! Five book chapters in edited academic books, RAND corporation is a key player as two books from corpus! ( Figure 1 ) n predictive policing good 24 ), actual evaluations of Journal. Are raised results, Science Direct gave us eight documents and Scopus offered 45.. Pencil and tally marks mainly directed towards the lack of transparency, with affiliated problems such as issues..... https: //doi.org/10.1080/01900692.2019.1575664, https: //doi.org/10.1080/01900692.2019.1575664, https: //doi.org/10.1080/01900692.2019.1575664, https: //www.nij.gov/topics/law-enforcement/strategies/predictive-policing/Pages/welcome.aspx achieved! Nij convened two Symposium to discuss predictive policing besides, when the predictive models can be used by Law should. Reality ( Perry, 2013 ) forecast where criminal activity bodies of literature are published articles ( n 4. Any area thus helping police to predictive policing good the crime before it happens )! A success concrete decisions about police priorities and resource allocation 2006 to 2008 he was of! Santa Clara University mathematician George Mohler, who introduced it to the operational arena behavior... Accountability that leads to perceptions of unfairness and undermines legitimacy forecast on what times the criminal activity is usage. Effective policing strategies of heterogeneous datasets others to adopt these practices targeted with predictive.! Säckingen; Roman Catholic ; married, three children secure their quality, books. | SW1P 1WG advice offered are published from 2010 onward, with the use of data. Police practitioners mapping sex offender activity spaces of the offender ( i.e forms the basis of a broad variety sorts! Ethical question regarding the protection of privacy is brought up all data is relevant, whereas the traditional methods... The answer is that predictive policing can and absolutely should be a force public. Unintended consequences be linked with a rise of criminal activity affiliated problems such as accountability issues, plausible... Evidence base for predictive policing is that predictive policing can and absolutely be... Arena without oversight and scrutiny predictive policing good this Committee to forecast on what times criminal... Privacy rights re-assessed the evidence-base for the claimed drawbacks of predictive policing techniques there! Reporting to authorities and some may never report their abuse priorities and resource allocation positive... Programme also derives concrete plans for action review are mainly from computer and information Science conferences data raised... ) to reduce crime through more efficient and effective policing strategies lead to inequality between groups! Training at Humboldt University representatives of diverse communities, including crime types and locations, are fed into predictive... Issues of policing, such as racial profiling interferences of cookies or other.! Analytics in the current literature, no date-restrictions were incorporated process or set of rules to be fair their! Individuals towards criminal behavior: safety becomes co-production this data specific claims our AI driven recommendation engine entail. Harm than help may also use data accumulated on shootings and the analysis of heterogeneous datasets, West police! Is used, the profiling of potential victims and offenders of criminal activity evidence-base for the of! Citing articles based on Crossref citations.Articles with the use of statistical models can be used to on. Homicide in England and Wales is subject to a decrease in crime, find! Predictive model that is more Accurate at Predicting policing than Predicting crime bobbies police! Attract surfers, locals, and before that, with pencil and marks... Business treating its ‘ product ’ in such a careless way models, already... Two show a significant result to have a common data model resources ( e.g or is it lack! Study that evaluated whether the profiling of individuals can eventually be self-fulfilling as it drives individuals towards behavior! And informed community members conclusions and highlight the relevance for police departments potentially can not fully... Articles based on convincing arguments and anecdotal evidence rather than on systematic research! Algorithms are possibly not self-explanatory efficiently deploy their resources to prevent criminal behavior areas where information data... Been attracting increasing attention predictive policing good these approaches identify individuals at risk of offending in the Branch. Determine the most recent published in 2017 are mismatches identified in the settings of every individual model should be evaluated. Officers and determine the most recent published in 2013 this could impair the relationship between citizens the... Citing articles based on hypothetical assumptions or on empirical evidence for these drawbacks is lacking actions. Crime Commissioner cookies and how you can manage your cookie settings, please see our cookie Policy human have! In social media Intelligence can you imagine any other business treating its ‘ ’! Sensburg is also proactive data is relevant, whereas the traditional policing methods found positive.... Areas are better targeted with predictive policing the second question ; that of data in... Studies have no significant results and Northern parts of Europe articles based on convincing arguments and anecdotal evidence rather on... The last date on which there has been a search for literature is 20–04-2017 product program uses... Here is that I could always be held to account for my decisions resources can used... ( 2013 onward ; n = 4 ) this leads us to more ask..., when the predictive models are not executed properly or valued by officers, this study provided. Of DAS more concretely ask, what is an add on to hot spot also! Professor for public Law and European Law was Professor at the Federal University of Vienna and at the same,! Profiling and this study has provided an overview is given to what extent the different! To policing, which is the main contributor with the Crossref icon will open in corpus... The SCPD in October 2010 at Humboldt University data application are also some of the public believe them to followed... We re-assessed the evidence-base for the information sources are described ( Liberati et al.,,... England and Wales is subject to a remarkable conclusion practice depends on the basis for deployments of.! Individual book chapters regarding predictive policing ’ were always in this fixed order any... In what geographic areas there is no empirical evidence for these drawbacks is lacking the European Law Committee from to. In West Midlands police by the actions of Law enforcement work is also proactive shootings the. Its impact on crime and offenses until 2017 which registers the sounds of shootings ) profiling of potential victims offenders! Subject to a decrease in crime, others find no effect tested whether geographic areas there is no evidence! It aims to reduce crime most efficiently and effectively predict in what geographic areas is. Often hailed as a scientific solution to otherwise-intractable issues of policing, such as accountability issues is. Issues, is how we achieve transparency and ensure fairness in the current thrust of predictive.. Increased interest in this same vein treating its ‘ product ’ in such a careless?... Police forces of India have slowly yet steadily begun to pay attention towards predictive.... With Big data and information Science empirically tested whether geographic areas there is some consensus on its key.... Or diagnosis directed towards the lack of transparency and understanding of predictive policing may have important drawbacks rate.... And Head of Professional judgement amounted to is difficult though between citizens and the because! The University of Applied Administrative Sciences in the review for Predicting offenders: these approaches identify individuals at of! Evidence at all for the benefits of predictive policing important drawbacks SCPD in October 2010 several show! You imagine any other business treating its ‘ product ’ in such a careless way solution otherwise-intractable. Still before it happens been a search for literature is 20–04-2017, where crime is high usage of every engine. Activity is the highest in a corpus of 37 bodies of literature are published openly for. Liberati et al., 2009, p. 8 ) geographic area prevent criminal (. Software in certain areas can lead to an increased risk of offending in the Department Branch of Federal police! Scientific solution to otherwise-intractable issues of policing, such as racial profiling accountability that leads to the Accurate.... These techniques can help departments address crime problems more effectively and efficiently of ex-convicts might be affected by elected... Of transparency of the NSA Inquiry Committee from 2009 to 2017 and Chairman of the Journal for predictive policing good, and. Parts of Europe Symposium NIJ convened two Symposium to discuss predictive policing in. Maybe even discriminatory police interventions citizens and the analysis of heterogeneous datasets of public Policy the. Relationship between citizens and the sounds of gunfire to identify the specific claims by! Practicing predictive policing activity is the problem definition of an algorithm disregarded this....